Theoria

The best responses to 1. e4

Against 1. e4, Black chooses between the symmetrical 1...e5 and the semi-open defenses, which answer from the side or let White build a center to attack later. Every reply below is played at the highest level and holds up in practice.

Pick by temperament. The Sicilian unbalances the game from the first move. The French and the Caro-Kann build solid pawn chains. 1...e5 keeps the game classical. The Pirc, Modern and Alekhine let White overextend before striking back.

Black’s replies to 1. e4

  1. Sicilian Defense

    1. e4 c5

    1...c5 trades a flank pawn for White’s center pawn and leads to imbalanced positions where both sides play to win. Black’s most popular reply at every level.

    4.7M games · Black scores 50%48%48%

  2. 1...e5 (the Open Game)

    1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nc6

    Black meets the center pawn with one of its own. The Ruy Lopez, Italian and Scotch follow, and Black has a fair share of the center from the start.

    4.4M games · Black scores 47%51%45%

  3. French Defense

    1. e4 e6

    1...e6 and 2...d5 build a solid chain and counterattack White’s center with ...c5 and ...f6. The price is the c8-bishop, which often stays behind its pawns.

    3.1M games · Black scores 50%48%48%

  4. Caro-Kann Defense

    1. e4 c6

    1...c6 and 2...d5 give a structure as sound as the French, with the light-squared bishop free to develop. Black accepts slightly passive positions for very few weaknesses.

    2.5M games · Black scores 50%48%48%

  5. Scandinavian Defense

    1. e4 d5

    1...d5 forces the issue on move one. Black’s queen comes out early, but the plans are clear and White has fewer ways to choose the kind of game.

    3.3M games · Black scores 49%49%48%

  6. Pirc Defense

    1. e4 d6

    1...d6, ...Nf6 and ...g6 let White build a broad center, then strike at it with ...e5 or ...c5. Flexible and full of counterplay, at the cost of space.

    1.2M games · Black scores 49%49%47%

  7. Modern Defense

    1. e4 g6

    1...g6 fianchettoes first and delays ...Nf6, keeping ...d6, ...c6 and ...c5 setups all in reserve.

    1.0M games · Black scores 49%49%48%

  8. Alekhine Defense

    1. e4 Nf6

    1...Nf6 invites White’s pawns forward so they become targets. Provocative, and far less mapped than the main defenses.

    547k games · Black scores 49%49%47%

Pick your openings, and Theoria turns them into one repertoire you can see as a tree and train move by move with spaced repetition. Free on the web, iOS and Android.

Build your repertoire

More opening guides